
As a Tasmanian small-scale farmer, I’ve watched a drying trend on my land over the past 15 years.
With that trend has come a huge uptick in thistles, particularly the dreaded spear thistle.
I’m no fan of chemicals. I cut down three trailer loads of thistles last year and burned them.
Reluctantly, this year I resorted to hand-spraying each thistle crown with broadleaf herbicide.
Doing a deep-dive into herbicides, I realised they stay in the soil longer than you might think.
Some break down into chemicals that are more toxic than the herbicide, and these also take time to break down.
Lastly, the original chemicals and the metabolites can be mobile in soil and water, and are toxic to aquatic life.
| Herbicide | Parent half-life in soil | Important metabolite | Metabolite half-life | Overall assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dicamba | 18–31 days | 3,6-DCSA | 6–28 days | Approximately 2–4 months |
| 2,4-D | 1.7–6.2 days in some studies | 2,4-DCP | No reliable soil half-life established | Generally weeks |
| MCPA | 7–41 days; some assessments report 15–50 days | 4-chloro-2-methylphenol | No reliable soil half-life established | Several weeks to several months |
Not sure what the answer is to getting rid of the thistles. Currently I am spraying each crown with a tiny amount.
The thistles grown in numbers sufficient to reduce pasture access for sheep.
Also keep in mind that farmers have a moral obligation to neighbours to be rid of thistles, as the wind-born seeds blow a long way.